Skip to content

Technology

Meta says it would 'consider' pulling its encrypted services from Canada — and Signal says it would leave

Testifying before the Senate national security committee on Monday evening, Meta said complying with Bill C-22 as written is "not technically feasible" while keeping end-to-end encryption. Signal repeated it would leave Canada rather than betray its users.

Published: November 16, 2026 · Updated: November 16, 2026 · 3 min read

Meta told senators on Monday evening that it would have to "consider" pulling its encrypted services from Canada if the government's lawful-access bill passes without further changes — the starkest warning yet from a tech company in the fight over Bill C-22.

"Ultimately, the Canadian government would be enforcing and imposing a law that it is not technically feasible to comply with and still offer secure, end-to-end encrypted services to Canadians," Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, told the Senate national security committee on Monday evening.

When asked whether that meant the company would pull some of its services from Canada, Meta's head of public policy for Canada, Rachel Curran, said the company would have to "review all of our options" — but that it was something it would have to "consider." Meta's services include Facebook, Instagram and the encrypted messaging app WhatsApp.

Signal repeats its warning — it would leave rather than betray users

Encrypted messaging service Signal has consistently said it would withdraw from Canada if the bill passes in its current form, and its vice-president Udbhav Tiwari repeated the warning to senators on Monday evening.

"If we are forced to choose between betraying our users and leaving Canada, we will not compromise the security of Canadians," Tiwari told the committee.

Tiwari called on the government to make further changes to the bill, including explicit assurances to protect encrypted data.

The amendments don't go far enough, the companies say

Bill C-22, the Lawful Access Act, 2026, would let the public safety minister issue confidential orders requiring electronic service providers to build lawful-access capabilities, and would let regulations require core providers to retain user metadata for up to six months. The bill passed the House of Commons on June 18 and is now before the Senate committee. It has not received royal assent, so none of its provisions is in force.

Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree proposed amendments before the bill went to the Senate, including limits on when companies would be required to decrypt information and cutting the maximum metadata retention period to six months from up to a year. But Curran told senators the amendments don't go far enough to protect encrypted data.

"They have protected just the core and not the outside layers that are an integral part of the encryption process," she said.

Apple also said earlier this month that the amendments aren't enough. "While we appreciate attempts to improve C-22, the bill could still undermine Apple's ability to offer the powerful privacy and security features our users expect from us, including encryption," the company said in a statement.

Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne has also urged the committee to amend the legislation further. The bill would lower the legal threshold for law enforcement and intelligence bodies to access basic subscriber information — names, addresses, telephone numbers, email addresses and account numbers — from "reasonable grounds to believe" down to "reasonable grounds to suspect" that an offence has been or will be committed. Dufresne said the definition of subscriber information and who can be asked to hand it over remain overly broad relative to that lowered threshold.

What it means for Canada

For Canadians, Monday's hearing was the moment the companies that run their messages told senators, in public, what the bill would force them to build — and what they would do if it passes. The government argues the bill is needed so law enforcement has the legal tools to prevent, investigate and respond to modern crime. This is the second lawful-access bill the government has introduced this session.

The committee can report the bill with or without amendments; if the Senate changes the text, the House must agree to identical wording before royal assent.

What matters

What happened

Meta told the Senate national security committee on Monday evening it would "consider" pulling encrypted services from Canada if Bill C-22 passes unchanged. Signal's Udbhav Tiwari said the company would leave Canada rather than betray its users.

Why it matters

Bill C-22 would let the public safety minister order providers to build intercept-ready systems and keep user metadata for up to six months — reaching anyone who relies on encrypted messaging such as WhatsApp or Signal in Canada.

What we know

Meta says complying while keeping end-to-end encryption is "not technically feasible." The minister's amendments limited decryption orders and cut metadata retention to six months, but Meta, Signal and Apple say they don't go far enough. The bill is not law — it has not received royal assent.

What we don’t

Whether senators press for the changes the companies and the Privacy Commissioner are requesting, whether the bill is amended, or whether Meta or Signal follow through on their warnings if it passes as written.

What’s next

The committee can report the bill with or without amendments. If the Senate changes the text, the House must agree to identical wording before royal assent.

Sources

PrivacyMetaSenateBill C-22SignalencryptionWhatsApp

Newsletter

News. Context. What matters.

One essential briefing, written for people who would rather understand the story than scroll it.

Unsubscribe anytime. We don’t sell addresses.

Recommended