Technology
Signal, Meta and Tailscale face senators tonight over Ottawa's bill to force apps to build intercept tools
The Senate national security committee hears from the tech companies at 6 p.m. ET Monday as it weighs Bill C-22, which would let the public safety minister order providers to build lawful-access capabilities and keep user metadata for up to six months.
Published: November 16, 2026 · Updated: November 16, 2026 · 3 min read
The companies that would have to comply with Ottawa's lawful-access bill face senators in Ottawa on Monday evening, in one of the most closely watched technology-policy hearings of the year.
The Senate national security committee will hear from Meta, Signal and Tailscale in a panel scheduled for 6 p.m. ET, as senators weigh Bill C-22, the Lawful Access Act, 2026. The meeting opens at 4 p.m. ET in Room W110, 1 Wellington St., with earlier panels hearing academics, privacy advocates and civil liberties groups.
Part 2 of the bill would let the public safety minister issue confidential ministerial orders requiring electronic service providers to build lawful access capabilities, and would let regulations require core providers to retain user metadata for up to six months. The bill passed the House of Commons on June 18 and was referred to the Senate committee on October 22. It has not received royal assent, so none of its provisions is in force.
Signal says it would leave Canada rather than break its encryption
Signal has been the bluntest of the three companies. Its executive Udbhav Tiwari told the House public safety committee in June that Part 2 conflicts with privacy rights, urged lawmakers to scrap it, and said Signal would leave a market rather than betray its users. In October he said complying would "fundamentally break Signal", and that Signal has never deliberately cut off a country.
Meta frames the problem as conscription. Rachel Curran told the Commons committee that Part 2 would allow the government to "conscript private companies into service as an arm of the government's surveillance apparatus." Apple and Google have also said the bill as written could require capabilities that weaken encryption, according to reporting on the companies' lobbying.
Tailscale objects on architecture. Its CEO, Avery Pennarun, said the issue is not lawful access for specific investigations but "mandatory, standing surveillance readiness", and that Part 2 would require providers to keep data that privacy laws, especially in Europe, bar them from storing. He said the company would challenge the law in court if it passes as written and would likely move if those challenges failed. About 40 per cent of Tailscale's global team is based in Canada.
The Salt Typhoon warning — and the government's answer
Critics point to the closest U.S. precedent: in 2024, the China-linked hacking group Salt Typhoon compromised American telecom wiretap systems built to fulfil requests under the U.S. Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act, reaching call and text metadata from more than a million users. Citizen Lab and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association argue this is the risk Part 2 would reproduce. Canada has its own exposure: the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security and the FBI said three Canadian telecom network devices were compromised in February 2025 by actors linked to Salt Typhoon.
The government says the bill was never meant to breach encryption. Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree said on May 27 that clearer language was coming, and the House added a provision stating the Act does not compel a provider to decrypt data unless the provider supplied the encryption and holds the key. Critics, including Signal and the Canadian Bar Association, say orders to share keys or change how a service works could still undermine encryption.
Supporters argue police cannot effectively investigate online extortion, child exploitation and organized crime with tools designed for an earlier era. The government's position is that Canada is the only G7 and Five Eyes country without a modern lawful access regime — a claim the Canadian Bar Association calls "only partly true", noting Canada already has modern interception tools but lacks a framework requiring providers to be ready to intercept.
What it means for Canada
For Canadians, Monday's hearing is the moment the companies that run their messages and VPNs tell senators, in public, what the bill would force them to build — and what they would do if it passes. At least 20 tech companies and industry groups wrote to ministers in September urging further amendments. Intelligence Commissioner Simon Noël and Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne have both asked senators for tighter safeguards. The committee can report the bill with or without amendments; if the Senate changes the text, the House must agree to identical wording before royal assent.
What matters
What happened
The Senate national security committee hears from Meta, Signal and Tailscale at 6 p.m. ET Monday as it weighs Bill C-22, the Lawful Access Act, 2026. The bill passed the House on June 18 and is now before the Senate.
Why it matters
Part 2 would let the public safety minister order providers to build intercept-ready systems and keep user metadata for up to six months — a change that would reach anyone who relies on encrypted messaging or a privacy-focused VPN in Canada.
What we know
Signal says it would leave Canada rather than weaken its encryption; Meta calls the bill conscription into surveillance; Tailscale says it would challenge the law in court. The government says the bill was never meant to break encryption, and the House added language limiting decryption orders.
What we don’t
Whether senators press for the changes the companies and commissioners are requesting, whether the bill is amended, or whether Signal or Tailscale follow through on their warnings if it passes as written.
What’s next
The committee can report the bill with or without amendments. If the Senate changes the text, the House must agree to identical wording before royal assent. Part 2 would start only on a date set by order of the Governor in Council.
Sources
PrivacyMetaSenateBill C-22SignalTailscaleencryption
Newsletter
News. Context. What matters.
One essential briefing, written for people who would rather understand the story than scroll it.
Unsubscribe anytime. We don’t sell addresses.
Recommended
Technology
Italy fines Meta $887 million for reading Android users' photos without consent
Italy's privacy regulator said Facebook accessed the photo galleries of about 20 million Android users without specific consent. Meta says it will appeal.
Technology
Microsoft 365 went down worldwide — Outlook, Teams and Copilot hit for more than 18 hours
A cascading failure that began Thursday evening left email and workplace tools unreachable across more than 70 countries. Microsoft says it was not a cyberattack — and service was still recovering on Friday.
Technology
Ottawa is buying into Cohere — up to $1.6 billion for a stake in Canada's AI champion
The federal government will take an equity stake in Toronto-based Cohere as part of a Series E round targeting up to $7 billion at a $35.7-billion valuation — the largest private financing ever raised by a Canadian tech company, and Ottawa's boldest bet yet on AI sovereignty.