Politics
Former Alberta medical deans urge Carney to block dual-practice health model
Four ex-deans say the province’s public-private surgery rules violate the Canada Health Act; Ottawa says talks with Edmonton continue while Alberta denies any breach.
Published: October 1, 2026 · 1 min read
Four former Alberta medical school deans have asked Prime Minister Mark Carney to intervene against the provinces dual-practice health-care model, arguing it creates a two-tier system that violates the Canada Health Act. Tom Feasby, Jon Meddings and Eldon Smith, formerly of the University of Calgary, and Tom Marrie, formerly of the University of Alberta, sent a letter Tuesday to Carney and Premier Danielle Smith expressing “deep concern. The model, in force since Sept. 1, lets some surgical specialists bill the public system while also charging private patients for procedures such as hip and knee replacements, cataract surgery and dermatology. The Canadian Medical Association and its Alberta counterpart have warned that patients who can pay may jump the queue. In an interview cited by The Globe and Mail, Meddings said Alberta’s scarce beds and physicians mean private cases are not “extra” capacity they displace someone who needed the spot. Federal Health Minister Marjorie Michel’s office said she is in targeted talks with Alberta Hospital and Surgical Health Services Minister Adriana LaGrange to protect access based on need. Alberta’s government insists dual practice does not breach the Canada Health Act, respects provincial jurisdiction, and expands choice without requiring Albertans to pay out of pocket for medically necessary care. Surgeries under the new pathway are expected later this fall after applications close. The dispute puts Carneys silence to a test: moral pressure on Edmonton, or the rarely used option of deducting federal health transfers if Ottawa concludes the Act has been broken. Sources: The Globe and Mail; CTV News Calgary.
Sources
- The Globe and Mail · other
- CTV News Calgary · other
- · other
- · other
- · other
- · other
Newsletter
News. Context. What matters.
One essential briefing, written for people who would rather understand the story than scroll it.
Unsubscribe anytime. We don’t sell addresses.
Recommended
Politics
Ottawa quietly froze a 16-helicopter Black Hawk buy for special forces as U.S. trade talks loomed, sources say
The UH-60M purchase had cleared the U.S. State Department and was headed to Congress when the Carney government hit pause, leaving commandos flying 30-year-old Griffons while officials weigh other options.
Politics
Poilievre takes his tariff-free auto pact to GM, Ford and Michigan union workers as the U.S. duty threatens to double
The Conservative leader crossed from Windsor into Detroit on Tuesday and rejected suggestions that the visit, weeks before the Nov. 3 U.S. midterms, amounts to meddling.
Politics
Eby defends his family’s $10-a-day child-care spot as B.C. Conservatives call it a scarce perk for a high-income household
The NDP leader says his child was already at a YMCA centre when it joined the program and that the family donated the fee difference; Conservatives say scarce spaces are going to people who do not need them.