Canada
The budget watchdog just warned Ottawa's borrowing is 'spectacularly out of whack' — $765 billion over five years
The Parliamentary Budget Officer says Ottawa will borrow 2.6 times its cumulative deficit to fund infrastructure, loans and defence — and debt charges will eat 13.6% of revenue by 2031.
Published: November 17, 2026 · Updated: November 17, 2026 · 3 min read
Canada's federal government risks leaving the treasury too exposed to rising interest rates from a surge in borrowing to fund resource and infrastructure projects and buy defence equipment, Parliament's budget watchdog warned in an analysis published Tuesday.
The Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer said Canada's borrowing requirement, based on the budget plan's projections, totals nearly C$765 billion (about US$535 billion) over five years — 2.6 times the cumulative budget deficit over the same period.
Borrowing and deficits are 'out of synch'
The warning builds on criticism from fiscal watchers who argue the government's borrowing requirements and its deficit profile are out of sync. Federal debt per capita is projected to grow 15 per cent over the next five years, the watchdog said, while public-debt charges per capita are expected to accelerate by 40 per cent.
The watchdog attributes the surge in interest costs to higher interest rates and to borrowing for loans, investments and capital purchases that the budget balance does not capture under accounting rules — some government expenses are not treated as budget expenses, and some capital purchases are expensed gradually through amortization.
By the fiscal year ending March 31, 2031, public-debt charges will account for 13.6 per cent of revenue, the watchdog said.
"If price pressures continue to intensify, and especially if fiscal concerns drive further increases in [bond yields], interest rates could rise higher than assumed," the watchdog said. "This would add to fiscal pressures through higher public debt charges, which are already the fastest-growing expense in the fiscal framework."
The budget spent almost all its fiscal room
In a separate finding from the same Tuesday report, the watchdog estimated that Budget 2026 adds C$151.5 billion of new measures over five years and leaves just C$6.8 billion of the C$158.3 billion in fiscal room the government had identified since the spring economic update. About C$89.5 billion of the package is labelled capital investment, much of it tied to a "Productivity Mega Deduction" meant to spur business spending, while C$62 billion goes to ongoing programs.
Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne defended the plan before lawmakers on Tuesday, arguing Canada has one of the strongest fiscal profiles among developed economies. "A confident country invests," he told the Senate finance committee, adding the planned spending is an effort to spur investment.
Critics say the debt is hidden in plain sight
The growth in borrowing is tied to an increase in non-budgetary transactions, such as loans to state-backed lenders and funds, and the acquisition of non-financial assets. That drew sharp criticism from the Toronto-based C.D. Howe Institute, which gave the budget plan a poor grade.
The deficit and debt profiles "were usually fairly in line. Now they are spectacularly out of whack," the think tank's president emeritus William Robson said on a podcast produced by the group. "The government is now raising all kinds of extra debt, and instead of using it to finance deficits, they're pushing it out as loans, investments, and advances."
Robson added that the concern for taxpayers should be what kind of returns these funds will generate, saying history points to low returns from government-funded initiatives. "Some of that money should be showing as spending and deficit, but instead they have moved it to a place where it's harder to see," he said.
What it means for Canadians
Debt charges are already the fastest-growing expense in the federal fiscal framework. If interest rates rise higher than the budget assumes, the cost of servicing the debt climbs with them — leaving less room for the services, transfers and tax measures households actually feel. With inflation stuck at 3.1 per cent and the Bank of Canada's next rate decision due December 9, the watchdog's warning lands at a moment when Ottawa's fiscal room is nearly spent and its borrowing is set to keep climbing.
What matters
What happened
The Parliamentary Budget Officer warned Tuesday that Ottawa will borrow nearly C$765 billion over five years — 2.6 times the cumulative deficit — and that debt charges will reach 13.6% of revenue by the fiscal year ending March 31, 2031.
Why it matters
Borrowing and deficits are now "spectacularly out of whack," in the C.D. Howe Institute's words, and debt charges are already the fastest-growing federal expense — leaving less room for everything else if rates rise.
What we know
The same PBO report says Budget 2026 adds C$151.5 billion in new measures over five years and leaves just C$6.8 billion of fiscal room. Finance Minister Champagne defended the plan in committee on Tuesday, saying "a confident country invests."
What we don’t
Whether the loans, investments and capital purchases driving the borrowing surge will generate the returns Ottawa is counting on — the core question the C.D. Howe Institute says history answers badly.
What’s next
The Bank of Canada's next rate decision is due December 9, with inflation stuck at 3.1%. The watchdog's warning will frame the fiscal debate in Parliament in the weeks ahead.
Sources
- Dow Jones via TradingView · other
- Finimize · other
- The Canadian Press via YouTube · other
Interest ratesMark Carneyfederal budgetFrançois-Philippe ChampagneParliamentary Budget OfficerdebtC.D. Howe Institute
Newsletter
News. Context. What matters.
One essential briefing, written for people who would rather understand the story than scroll it.
Unsubscribe anytime. We don’t sell addresses.
Recommended
Canada
Carney's budget just passed the House 162–151 — and the threat of an early election is gone
MPs approved Budget 2026 on Thursday evening, giving the Liberals a major win on a confidence vote. The spending plan now faces implementation bills that can still be amended.
Canada
"If the U.S. doesn't want to do a deal, we're busy," Carney says — as Canada signs trade pacts elsewhere
Speaking hours after his 20-minute meeting with Trump in Shenzhen, the prime minister said a "very good" U.S. trade arrangement is possible but "not yet there" — while Canada's deals with ASEAN, the Philippines and China move ahead.
Canada
Assisted-dying bill clears second reading 225–89 — after the Liberals cut off debate
Bill C-41 would let Canadians with dementia or ALS make advance requests for medical assistance in dying — and permanently block MAID for mental illness alone. It now goes to committee with a March 17 deadline.